Mobility/Micromobility/Analysis/ The big scooter bounce back begins Scooter operators have had a hard few months — but now they're springing back into action. Who's taken the lead? By Amy Lewin 3 June 2020 \Mobility Was the $5bn that VCs plugged into escooters worth it? By Sadia Nowshin, Tim Smith and Mimi Billing 16 February 2023 Mobility/Micromobility/Analysis/ The big scooter bounce back begins Scooter operators have had a hard few months — but now they're springing back into action. Who's taken the lead? By Amy Lewin 3 June 2020 Lockdowns across Europe were not great for scooter startups. Usage plummeted as tourists disappeared from city centres, locals stayed in their houses and even workers who were venturing out were concerned about just how hygienic shared transport really is. Swedish scooter operator Voi shut down operations in all but six of its markets. Berlin-based Tier postponed a launch in Rome, pulled out of Turin and Malaga and scaled back across all markets. US operator Lime stopped services in Europe completely. But now, as lockdowns relax and cities start moving again, the great bounce back begins. How are the competitors faring? We look at the data. Usage today Scooters are a seasonal business — usage peaks in the summer, and dive bombs in winter — which makes comparing how many rides are taken in May to how many rides were taken in February somewhat wonky. The scooter market is also still a very young one — most operators have been in business less than two years — so making comparisons to this time last year (when most operators were live in far fewer markets) also has its flaws. Still, Dott says usage of its scooters jumped back to pre-Covid levels in all cities when lockdowns ended: on Monday 11 May people took the same number of rides as on Monday 9 March. Now usage is even higher, the company says. Looking at Paris in particular, Dott says its operations in the city are back to profitability and each scooter is making four rides per day. It seems that lockdown has also made Parisians better citizens; a higher percentage of rides are now ending in official parking zones (97%), compared to 83% in February. Tier’s operations remain closed in Italy and Spain, but Roger Hassan, chief operating officer, says that overall usage is not too bad. “We’re at levels we were seeing in October last year,” he says; not quite the numbers the company was hoping for in May, but not a disaster. Germany and the Nordics are making quite a big comeback, he adds. Meanwhile, Voi says usage is back up to 50% compared to last May. Scooter app downloads from Germany, Austria, Switzerland, France, Norway, Sweden, Finland and Denmark. Source: App Annie. Peak lockdown “From February to March, usage dropped dramatically, with cities seeing somewhere between zero and 20% of what had gone before,” says Voi, which paused operations in 30 cities when governments ordered people to stay indoors. “At that stage there was little point in having scooters on the streets, especially as we wanted people to comply with lockdown.” Tier shut down 14 cities (out of 59) and, in the worst week of lockdown, saw usage hit perhaps a tenth of peak summer volume, says Hassan — or around 50% of pre-Covid, low-season usage. Lime, which stopped operations in all markets, saw a 100% drop in usage. Meanwhile Dott, the smaller Amsterdam-based scooter operator, maintained a limited service in all nine of its cities. In France, this meant it accounted for nearly all scooter activity in April (97.6%). Scooter app reviews. Source: Micromobility Industries. Looking at app reviews, Tier has had a great time in comparison to its (global) competitors. At one point during lockdown, 20.1% of global scooter activity was provided by Tier, according to the Micromobility Industries blog. Hassan reckons this is because many of the US providers aren’t using swappable batteries in Europe yet, which leads to higher operational overheads. When utilisation is low, those overheads become even harder to justify. Free rides for key workers Call it marketing ploy, act of kindness or both, several of the scooter operators announced schemes to let essential workers use their vehicles for free during lockdown. Tier says it handed out 1.5m free minutes to front-line workers to help them travel safely (riders were entitled to up to 15 minutes free at a time). Dott formed 70 partnerships with healthcare organisations and essential shops to help their staff get into work safely, and gave out 15,000 free rides to healthcare workers. Voi has increased the number of scooters it places near hospitals, offered free rides to healthcare workers in Paris, Lyon, Berlin, Stockholm and Oslo, and lent scooters to doctors in Paris. Lime partnered with Parisian hospital system AP-HP to offer healthcare workers free rides. A Dott scooter in Paris. New city launches Even lockdown didn’t stop some of the scooter operators launching new cities. Tier has launched in five news cities since early March, including Trondheim in Norway and Uppsala in Sweden. Voi also launched in Trondheim — and Zurich — over the past two months, while Lime has recently launched in Rome and Krakow. Meanwhile, Dott launched in Warsaw at the start of May, and will be launching in several Italian cities this week. It also has a Germany city launch in the works. Tier says it plans to launch in a further five to six cities in the coming weeks (three of which will be in Germany). All of the main operators in Europe will also be hoping to launch in several cities in the UK in the coming months. New habits Scooter users are spending more time on the vehicles than they were before the pandemic hit. Tier has seen a 20% global increase in ride duration, trips taken on Voi’s scooters are almost double as long as pre-Covid (now 18 minutes on average), while Lime says it’s seeing rides in Europe that are 25% longer on average. Scooter companies are also reporting more journeys starting and ending in residential areas. This — along with the longer ride times — suggests that scooters are being used more for utility than for sightseeing at the moment. “Riders now are locals focused on commute and essential trips.” “Riders now are locals focused on commute and essential trips,” says Lime. Voi has expanded its operational zones in all cities to cater to these users. Taking a scooter has also become better value, for the meantime. “We see increased distance travelled per minute,” says Lime. There are fewer cars on the roads, and more space given over to micromobility, which means riders can whizz along faster. In comparison to last year, rides are around 20% faster in Germany, Austria and Switzerland and 33% faster in Greece. Riders are also using scooters more times per day; in Budapest, Lime trips per day are up by 26% and in Bucharest, up 18%. Active Voi users are taking more trips per week; the company has launched a loyalty programme for these frequent users, to make trips more affordable the more they ride. A green recovery Beyond capturing new markets, scooter operators are also hoping to capture the hearts of politicians looking for greener ways to get their countries moving again. “Shared e-scooters will offer a sustainable, affordable and socially-distanced transport option in towns and cities across the country. As people begin to travel back into work, e-scooters can help fill the gaps caused by reduced public transport capacity,” says Alan Clarke, head of policy and government relations in the UK at Lime. The danger is that cars replace public transport, not scooters. “That’s the single biggest threat,” says Hassan at Tier. “If [local authorities] don’t provide an alternative, the next logical outcome is a car-based recovery. We need to work fast and be really careful that that is not what happens.” Related Articles Now is the moment for European cities to get a move on and leave cars behind By Emily Brooke Click here to read more Scooter wars are back on — in the UK By Amy Lewin Click here to read more Electric scooters: not so “green” after all By Amy Lewin Click here to read more Most Read 1 \Healthtech Is Daniel Ek’s new body scanner worth the hype? Sifted tried it out 2 \Venture Capital VC diversity needs to change — and white men need to take responsibility 3 \Venture Capital New €3.75bn European Investment Fund pot to back late-stage VCs 4 \Sustainability Counteract closes £15m fund for carbon removal solutions 5 \Mobility Was the $5bn that VCs plugged into escooters worth it?